Showing posts with label independent state legislature theory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label independent state legislature theory. Show all posts

Friday, June 28, 2024

Republicans Want to Revive the Independent State Legislature Theory A Year after already rejected by Supreme Court

A year ago, the U.S. Supreme Court rejected the radical independent state legislature theory in Moore v. Harper. Now, Republicans in Pennsylvania and Montana are asking SCOTUS to consider the theory again to give lawmakers unprecedented power in elections.

Thursday, June 29, 2023

US supreme court rules against fringe legal theory in key voting rights case

The ruling is a blow to North Carolina Republicans who had asked the court to embrace the so-called independent state legislature theory – the idea that the US constitution does not allow state courts to limit the power of state legislatures when it comes to federal elections. There was deep concern that embracing such an idea would upend US elections, essentially giving legislatures a blank check to write election laws without oversight from state courts. It would have been a massive win for Republicans, who control more state legislatures than Democrats do. 

The court's decision means that state courts can continue to weigh in on disputes over federal election rules. State courts have become increasingly popular forums for hearing those disputes, especially after the US supreme court said in 2019 that federal courts could not address partisan gerrymandering...


Sunday, February 19, 2023

The North Carolina Supreme Court has thrown SCOTUS a lifeline | The Hill

If SCOTUS were to approve the theory, it would give strong support to the scheme that Thomas's former clerk John Eastman hatched to change the outcome of the 2020 presidential election. Eastman claimed that state legislatures, acting alone, can present alternate elector slates in a presidential election, regardless of the popular vote. Eastman corresponded with Thomas's wife, Ginni, about the scheme and she, in turn, vigorously pursued it. Eastman even professed to have inside information about a "heated fight" among SCOTUS justices as the scheme unfolded. This documented and publicly available information reeks of impropriety. 

Thomas should immediately withdraw from the case because of his glaring conflict of interest. It is inconceivable that he would participate in a case that could give legs in 2024 to the scheme that his wife and former clerk advanced to commandeer the 2020 election. SCOTUS is coming under increasing pressure to adopt a code of conduct, which would include standards for recusal. Thomas's participation in any final decision of the Moore case would have a devastating impact on the high court's legitimacy.


Sunday, December 11, 2022

Supreme Court elections case: Moore v. Harper would give Trump’s Jan. 6 coup a bogus constitutional pass.

That's the argument that the Supreme Court considered, and rejected, in Bush v. Gore. (A young Bush lawyer named Brett Kavanaugh was especially enamored of it.) It's the argument that Trump deployed when he tried to nullify millions of votes in 2020. And it's the argument that Ginni Thomas, wife of Justice Clarence Thomas, relied upon when lobbying state legislators to appoint "alternate electors" who would support Trump. And to be fair, it has some superficial appeal: Its proponents like to say that "legislature means legislature," and that's the end of it. 
 But it's really not, for at least four reasons. First, when the Constitution was written, in 1787, legislature meant more than the specific body of elected representatives who pass laws. The word encompasses the entire power that makes laws—which is why, for instance, a governor can veto a congressional map...


Tuesday, December 6, 2022

Ask PolitiFact: What is independent state legislature theory, and could it create election chaos? - PolitiFact

If the justices fully backed the doctrine, state courts could no longer apply state constitutions to adjudicate partisan gerrymandering claims involving congressional districts, said Bertrall Ross, a University of Virginia law professor. That would likely lead to more extreme gerrymandering, he said. Also, the most extreme reading of the theory could jeopardize voter-approved changes to state election laws, such as Michigan voters' approval of no-excuse absentee voting, Alaska's adoption of ranked choice voting and Nevada's adoption of automatic voter registration…


Tuesday, October 4, 2022

How the Supreme Court could give Republicans more power to influence elections - The Washington Post

It begins with another question about potentially illegal gerrymandering, this time in North Carolina, and whether Republican state lawmakers violated that state's Constitution by drawing overtly political maps. Here the justices are looking at a broad question of how much power courts should have over state legislatures...


There Is Not an ‘Independent State Legislature’ - The Atlantic

Such a doctrine would be antithetical to the Framers' intent, and to the text, fundamental design, and architecture of the Constitution...


Wednesday, September 21, 2022

They overturned Roe and, amid the chaos, gutted 12 more rights and freedoms you might have missed

These 12 decisions demonstrate why the legitimacy of the court is in question. It's not "simply because people disagree with an opinion," as Chief Justice John Roberts whined earlier this month. It's because the radical, extreme majority has been dismantling core tenets of the Constitution and settled law, undermining the will of the majority of Americans, throwing out decades—even centuries—of precedent, and demonstrating that it is an existential threat to the rule of law.

The court's next term, starting in just two weeks, will feature cases that threaten LGBTQ rights, environmental safety, election integrity, affirmative action, and more. That includes Moore v. Harper, an effort by Republican legislators in North Carolina to declare themselves the sole arbiters of federal elections, putting them above the state's constitution and the state's courts. The specious and radical theory they're arguing—the "independent state legislature" theory—is based on an early 19th-century document that "is a well-known fake." In other words: fraud…
https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2022/9/19/2123887/-They-overturned-Roe-and-in-the-chaos-gutted-12-more-rights-and-freedoms-you-might-have-missed


Thursday, July 7, 2022

The US supreme court is turning the constitution into a suicide pact

…If all this were not bad enough, the court ended its present term by announcing that it had agreed to hear Moore v Harper in the fall. It is widely feared that the case, which involves a North Carolina redistricting plan, will provide the court's reactionary core the opportunity to adopt the so-called "independent state legislature theory", a previously fringe notion that the constitution gives state legislatures plenary control over elections, free from the oversight of state courts and regardless of contrary provisions in state constitutions. Adopting this dangerous theory could, for example, give legislators spouting the big lie in swing states the power to determine the outcome of a presidential election. Whatever theory we use to interpret the constitution, it should not result in the destruction of the very form of democratic governance the constitution was designed to protect… 









Click Older Posts above to see more.